Screw Caps, Robert Parker, & Oak Chips - Our Favorite Controversies

If you find yourself sitting next to your brother-in-law (let’s call him Andy) at some obligatory BBQ this summer, and he decides he wants to pick an argument, here are some of the topics he might present: The war. Gay marriage. The legitimacy of country music. Screw caps versus cork.

Ok, so the word “controversial” doesn’t often bring to mind a series of wine topics. But they are out there. And like the war, or gay marriage, or the legitimacy of country music, you’ll find plenty of people ready to debate the merits of both sides. Given that wine is a nonessential, pleasure-heavy product, it seems rather frivolous to come to blows with someone about anything wine-related. However, for winemakers and winery owners, retailers and enthusiasts, controversial wine topics often affect more than their sense of being right or wrong. Such questions can affect their livelihood. And that is always grounds for defense (or offense, as the case may be).

So what are some of the top controversies that spark debate amongst otherwise reasonable, rational people? A few to consider:

Robert Parker: This man single handedly changed the way scores of wine producers market their wines, and in many cases, the way they make their wines. If you’re a winemaker, you either love him (because he gave you a high score and therefore vastly improved your sales, reputation and credibility), or hate him, (because he gave you an embarrassing score, he’s ignored you completely, or you’re just philosophically opposed to his existence).